The 9 Best Gemstone Subscription Boxes for 2024

  • By: Ryan Kane
  • Updated: February 21, 2024
  • Time to read: 7 min.
Affiliate Disclaimer

As an affiliate, we may receive commissions for purchases made through links on this website.

The best gemstone monthly subscription boxes include Mindful Souls, the Crystal Variety Box, and the Natural Stone Collection Box. Each box includes unique gemstones. Read on for a comparison of each box, so you can decide which is right for you.

It’s easy to get overwhelmed by the number of gemstone boxes out there. In this article, we’ve worked through the top gemstone subscription boxes, including details about each, pricing, and reviews, so that with a quick scan, you can sort out which looks like the best fit for you.

We also have separate guides specifically diving into spirituality subscription boxes, meditation subscription boxes, and mindfulness subscription boxes.

Without further ado, let’s explore the top gemstone subscription boxes.

Best Overall Gem Subscription Boxes

If you’re looking for a quick answer, here are the top three gemstone boxes with the best mix of value and quality. Each has hundreds (or thousands) of happy customers—if you pick one of these, you’ll be happy.

Best Gemstone Variety
Highest-Quality Crystals
Best for Crystal Jewelry
4.4
4.8
4.7
$35.00
$18.00
$39.97

If you collect gemstones or work in crystal or spiritual healing, this box is for you. Each month you'll get 5-10 beautiful stone cabochons, carefully labeled and packedplus at least one extra! Items include uncommon stones, hard-to-find agates, and more.

It doesn't get simpler than this: you'll get one new, extremely high-quality crystal sent to your door each month. These aren't just any items; these are large, uncommon, striking stones like silver sheen obsidian, amethysts, and strawberry quartz obelisks. If you want to supplement your collection with amazing crystals, this is the box for you.

If you’re looking for a more spiritual angle to your practice, consider Mindful Souls. Each Mindful Souls box includes 6-8 hand-picked items, like crystal jewelry, raw crystals, aromatherapy, affirmation cards and more. 

Best Gemstone Variety
4.4
$35.00

If you collect gemstones or work in crystal or spiritual healing, this box is for you. Each month you'll get 5-10 beautiful stone cabochons, carefully labeled and packedplus at least one extra! Items include uncommon stones, hard-to-find agates, and more.

Highest-Quality Crystals
4.8
$18.00

It doesn't get simpler than this: you'll get one new, extremely high-quality crystal sent to your door each month. These aren't just any items; these are large, uncommon, striking stones like silver sheen obsidian, amethysts, and strawberry quartz obelisks. If you want to supplement your collection with amazing crystals, this is the box for you.

Best for Crystal Jewelry
4.7
$39.97

If you’re looking for a more spiritual angle to your practice, consider Mindful Souls. Each Mindful Souls box includes 6-8 hand-picked items, like crystal jewelry, raw crystals, aromatherapy, affirmation cards and more. 

For a deep-dive into all options, read on below.

1. Mindful Souls

Best Overall Mindful Box
Mindful Souls
$39.97

If you’re looking for a more spiritual angle to your practice, consider Mindful Souls. Each Mindful Souls box includes 6-8 hand-picked items, like crystal jewelry, raw crystals, aromatherapy, affirmation cards and more. 

Pros:
  • Comprehensive holistic wellness tools including gemstone jewelry and aromatherapy products
  • A bargain each month, with 6-8 self-care products worth over $100
  • Ethically-sourced items, shipped promptly with clear instructions
Cons:
  • Some competing boxes include more items
Buy Now See Our Review
We earn a commission if you make a purchase, at no additional cost to you.

Summary: With 100,000 happy customers and free shipping, Mindful Souls is a fantastic way to get more gemstones into your life.

Each Mindful Souls box includes 6-8 hand-picked items, like:

  • Powerful crystals
  • Gemstone jewellery
  • Relaxing aromatherapy
  • Natural beauty products
  • Mindful talismans
  • Monthly affirmations

Each box also includes instructions on how to use these tools, and descriptions of each. They bill themselves as being “almost like having a spiritual mentor with you.” 

Mindful Souls Review:  “This box is my favorite. I find myself wearing the jewelry, displaying the crystals, and just overall excited to see what comes next.” – Robin D.

Read more in our Mindful Souls box overview, where we do a deep dive into exactly which items a few of the boxes contain.

2. Crystal Variety Box

Best Value for Crystals
Crystal Variety Box
$42.00

A monthly variety box of crystals and stones carefully curated and sourced from all over the world. Includes 4-6 crystals or mineral specimens, and a newly-designed and hand-crafted cloth grid every month.

Pros:
  • Each crystal includes a QR code so you can learn where it's from, plus metaphysical properties
  • "Crystal of the Month" plan is perfect for new crystal collectors building out their collection
  • Each crystal is labeled and individually wrapped
Cons:
  • It's only crystals—so if you're looking for something more, you're out of luck
Current Deals:
Get 100% Off Your First Box
We earn a commission if you make a purchase, at no additional cost to you.

Who It’s For: If you’re focused on maximizing the gemstones you receive (rather than gemstones plus lots of extras) this box might be the best-value way to grow your collection.

Summary: For the sheer enormity and diversity of its selection, it’s tough to beat the Crystal Variety Box. These crystals are hand-picked by an in-house team and shipped using recyclable, eco-friendly materials. You’ll get 4-6 crystals in each box, originating from all over the world, and each comes with a cloth grid. For newbies, there’s a Crystal of the Month club that slowly introduces you to the essentials as you build out your crystal collection. Free shipping to the United States.  

Crystal Variety Box Review: “They give such an awesome group of crystals every month that help my collection grow and grow. I’m always excited to see what is coming next.” – Alisa L.

3. Crystal of the Month Box

Best for High-Quality Crystals
Crystal of the Month Club
$18.00

It doesn't get simpler than this: you'll get one new, extremely high-quality crystal sent to your door each month. These aren't just any items; these are large, uncommon, striking stones like silver sheen obsidian, amethysts, and strawberry quartz obelisks. If you want to supplement your collection with amazing crystals, this is the box for you.

Pros:
  • Each crystal is valued at $25+
  • Fantastic way to grow your crystal collection on a budget
  • Uncommonly beautiful crystals
Cons:
  • If you want more than one crystal per month, this isn't the box for you
Current Deals:
Get 50% Off Your First Box
We earn a commission if you make a purchase, at no additional cost to you.

Who it’s for: Crystal collectors wanting to grow their collection with uncommonly beautiful stones.

Review: “This silver sheen obsidian is sooooo pretty. I’ve heard of gold sheen obsidian but never silver and I have to say I think this is one of my new favorites in my collection. This was my first month so I can’t wait to see what I get next month!” – Michaela

4. Natural Stone Cabochons & Gemstone Collection Box

Best Variety of Gemstones
Natural Stone Cabochon Collection Box
$35.00

If you collect gemstones or work in crystal or spiritual healing, this box is for you. Each month you'll get 5-10 beautiful stone cabochons, carefully labeled and packedplus at least one extra! Items include uncommon stones, hard-to-find agates, and more.

Pros:
  • Get beautiful, unique stones each month
  • Perfect for jewelry artists
  • Informational cards for each stone
Cons:
  • Relatively small box of items
Buy Now
We earn a commission if you make a purchase, at no additional cost to you.

Who It’s For: Gemstone collectors, jewelry artists, and crystal healers.

Summary: If you’re looking for a gemstone mystery box, you’ve come to the right place. The Natural Stone Cabochon Collection box includes 5-9 gorgeous stones each month. Each is carefully labeled. These aren’t just any ordinary stones: the box is full of unusual, hard-to-find gemstones that are sure to round out your collection with something unique. If you’re a jewelry artist looking for inspiration, a healer, or simply a crystal enthusiast and collector, this gem subscription box is for you. 

Natural Stone Collection Box Review: “Just WOW!!! I have ordered a lot of crystal subscription boxes and this is by far one of the BEST ones. It is so perfectly packaged, everything is so so beautiful and I love the notepad and pen I received in my box also. I am so excited for next month’s already!!!” – Emily B.

5. Goddess Provisions

Best Value Spiritual Box
Goddess Provisions
$33.00

With 1800+ reviews and 17000+ sales, you can't go wrong with Goddess Provisions. Each monthly box includes 5-7 products (total value $80-$100) including a mix of crystals, aromatherapy, natural beauty products, superfood snacks & spiritual tools.

Pros:
  • All the products are vegan, cruelty-free and natural
  • The boxes are often curated around a theme, like “Sacred Cycles"
  • Thousands of happy customers
Cons:
  • As of December 2023, boxes are no longer freshly curated, so long-term subscribers will eventually get repeat items
Buy Now Our Review
We earn a commission if you make a purchase, at no additional cost to you.

With 1800+ reviews and 17000+ sales, the Goddess Provisions Box is one of the most popular witchy subscription boxes available.  

Summary: The purpose of each Goddess Provisions box is to “nurture your inner goddess and help grow your spiritual practice.” Each monthly box includes 5 to 7 full-size products (total value $80-$100). Typically included are a mix of crystals, aromatherapy, natural beauty products, superfood snacks & spiritual tools. All the products are vegan, cruelty-free and natural

You won’t get much better than Goddess Provisions if you’re looking for creative items to fuel your spiritual journey each month. The boxes are often curated around a theme, like “Sacred Cycles.” The hundreds of reviews are full of raving fans, and many talk about how packed with value these boxes are (“I think it’s rare to get a full deck of oracle cards in a $33 box”). Goddess Provisions ships worldwide and has free shipping to the United States.

Goddess Provisions Review: “Absolutely LOVE Goddess Provisions! It has greatly increased my supply of witchy things- every month me and my daughter look forward to opening it together and I’m always happy with the things they pick each month. It is definitely worth the cost each month for how much we get!” – Margaret S.

Further reading: If you’re considering the Goddess Provisions Box, check out our overview of exactly what comes in each Goddess Provisions Box here.

6. The Witches Roots

Best Overall Witchy Box
The Witches Roots
$24.00

For anyone interested in magickal items, rituals, and natural crafts. Commonly includes items like dried herbs & magickal flowers, ritual body oils, spell coins or magickal talismans, incense, spell candles, crystals, and custom artwork.

Pros:
  • Carefully curated tools for herbal witchcraft
  • Items reflect seasonal themes
  • Includes educational content for practitioners
Cons:
  • Not customizable for individual allergies
Current Deals:
Get 25% Off Your First Box
We earn a commission if you make a purchase, at no additional cost to you.

Who It’s For: Individuals interested in magickal items, rituals, and natural crafts.

Summary: The Witches Roots by The Witches Moon is a carefully crafted subscription service filled with items designed to enhance the magick in your life. These items may include dried herbs & magickal flowers, ritual body oils, spell coins or magickal talismans, incense, spell candles, crystals, and custom artwork.

The Witches Roots Reviews:

  1. Karen C. (★★★★★): “I love everything I got! And this helped me to start my book of shadow. I cannot wait to receive the next one. I already put my Brigid’s cross on my window!”
  2. Angie A. (★★★★★): “I loved everything that was in the box… This box was such a gift. I got it on Monday afternoon. Sat in the sunshine and opened it. Everything in it was something I needed. You brightened my day. I was going to make it a one-time deal but I can’t give it up. Thank you!!!”

7. Magickal Earth

Great for Astrology Fans
Magickal Earth
$52.00

Magickal Earth supplements its monthly crystals with astrology and tarot products. Each hand-curated box is designed around what’s happening on the astrological calendar or what’s happening with the seasons, and each tarot card is drawn just for you. Every month, you can expect to receive crystals, astrology calendar and horoscope, tarot card, and written explanations to put everything into context.

Pros:
  • Whether it's spring, summer, fall, winter, or mercury retrograde, every box takes the monthly cycle into account
  • Tarot card drawn just for you
  • Information about each crystal
Cons:
  • Some customers mention the quality of the crystals wasn't as premium as they expected
Current Deals:
Get 50% Off Your First Box
We earn a commission if you make a purchase, at no additional cost to you.

Who It’s For: Astrology and tarot enthusiasts building their gemstone collections.

Summary: Magickal Earth supplements its monthly crystals with astrology and tarot products. Each hand-curated box is designed around what’s happening on the astrological calendar or what’s happening with the seasons, and each tarot card is drawn just for you. Every month, you can expect to receive crystals, astrology calendar and horoscope, tarot card, and written explanations to put everything into context.

Magickal Earth Subscription Box Review: “This was a lovely box! A tarot, the astrological calendar, a beautiful selection of crystals, a leather pouch and beads to sew my own design on it, and so much more. The quality of the crystals, calendar, and tarot card are what convinced me to sign up for a 3 month plan.” – Kathryn P.

8. The Witches Bounty

Great for Metaphysical Jewelry
The Witches Bounty
$78.00

The Witches Bounty focuses on providing the highest quality crystal & metaphysical necklaces and pendants each month. Products are stored in Sedona, Arizona, a place known for its energy vortexes.

Pros:
  • Stunning, high-quality jewelry (that you'll actually wear)
  • Hand-crafted anointing oils
  • Each box is created based on the energies of the year
Cons:
  • Relatively pricey (though for most, the quality is worth it)
Buy Now
We earn a commission if you make a purchase, at no additional cost to you.

Who It’s For: People drawn to metaphysical products, particularly crystal and metaphysical pendants, and anointing oils.

Summary: The Witches Bounty, by The Witches Moon, is a subscription service delivering monthly boxes filled with high-quality, one-of-a-kind metaphysical pendants, associated crystals, handmade anointing oils, and some of the best gemstone jewelry you’ll find. Stored in Sedona, Arizona, known for its energy vortexes and metaphysical communities, each box is curated in line with the energies of the year.

The Witches Bounty Reviews:

  1. Amy T. (★★★★★): “I’m entirely impressed with the December 2021 box!!! You have definitely mastered bringing something new to the craft. Thank you so much!
  2. Sav R. (★★★★★): “I love all the witches moon boxes…. The main piece was a herkemir diamond and it is just amazing! Rest was lovely!

9. Tamed Wild

Perfect for Earth Medicine Lovers
Tamed Wild
$50.00

The Tamed Wild Seasonal Box focuses on earth medicine, including crystals, herbs, teas, altar items, jewelry, essential oils and more. Each box includes 10-12 items along with artisan blended tea.

Pros:
  • Diverse items like crystals, herbs, teas, and essential oils
  • With 10-12 items included, you'll get more than most boxes
  • Customers love the carefully-designed seasonal themes
Cons:
  • Only comes once every three months
Buy Now
We earn a commission if you make a purchase, at no additional cost to you.

Summary: The Tamed Wild Box focuses on earth medicine, including crystals, herbs, teas, altar items, jewelry, essential oils and more. Each box includes 10-12 items along with artisan blended tea, and is intended to grow your spiritual practice with monthly tools. Also included are descriptions of each item, so you can continue learning each month. Everything included uses organic ingredients.

Tamed Wild Box Reviews: “Absolutely stellar box! The printed inserts are packed with cool information, and the variety and beauty of the items is always impressive. I’m overwhelmed by the number of gorgeous things sent at this price, and the packaging is just a joy to open up.” – Chelsea M.