Mindfulness vs Multitasking: Which is Better?

  • By: Ryan Kane
  • Updated: February 2, 2022
  • Time to read: 5 min.

It’s a debate as old as the first conversation about productivity:

Should I multitask to get more done? Or just focus on one thing at a time?

Mindfulness is closely associated with monotasking, or focusing on a single task at time. Although the research is clear that multitasking tends to lower productivity, the debate goes on. Some people claim that multitasking simply works better for them; and then there’s the magical-sounding group of so-called supertaskers, the 2.5% of us who excel at multitasking.

Below, we’ll explore each of these angles in the debate about multitasking, all in the context of mindfulness.

Mindfulness vs multitasking

First, let’s note that we can’t exactly compare mindfulness and multitasking. Monotasking and multitasking is the appropriate comparison. But because monotasking is closely associated with mindfulness, many people wonder which “approach” to getting their tasks done is better.

The main difference between mindfulness and multitasking is that mindfulness is associated with deep focus and concentration on a single activity, whereas multitasking involves doing multiple tasks simultaneously, or “task switching,” which refers to jumping between tasks.

With a mindful approach to getting things done, you’d pick a single thing to work on, and then work on only that. When you find yourself getting distracted, or being drawn towards other tasks, you’d gently bring yourself back to the original task at hand. Or, if you did decide to switch tasks, you’d stay singularly focused on the new task.

Multitasking is the habit of doing multiple tasks at once, or task switching between different activities. This can refer to anything from talking on the phone while driving your car, to listening to a podcast while writing, to having a dozen browser tabs open and jumping between them. Proponents of multitasking may have specific reasons for jumping between tasks. For example, if your job involves both managing people and getting work of your own done, you may be drawn by the demands of the day towards jumping back and forth between the two.

Personal preference, habits and the particulars of a work environment can all weigh in on the decision to multitask or monotask.

Is multitasking bad for mindfulness?

Multitasking is typically considered at odds with mindfulness because it’s frequently driven by distraction, as well as an accommodation of external demands on our time, rather than our own priorities.

When we sit down to make progress on a project, and decide to handle incoming emails, phone calls and employee requests at the same time, we’re missing the chance to apply all of our focus to our most important task. We also miss the chance to create and stick to our own intention for how we’d like to use that time.

A mindful approach to the day would instead involve setting our own priorities and goals, creating space for each priority, and giving the full power of our attention to each one.

Of course, this is hard and sometimes unrealistic, given that modern workplaces provide significant distraction and that our brains are wired for distraction in the first place.

For these reasons, even though we may want to monotask, we often multitask.

Why is the brain bad at multitasking? (Here’s what the research says)

In a review of multitasking and mindfulness literature, Suzanne K Powell finds:

“Research shows that multitasking lowers IQ, shrinks the gray matter, and lowers productivity by 40%. Conversely, mindfulness increases gray matter and improves regions involved with learning and memory processes, modulation of emotional control, and the process of awareness.”

It’s generally understand in the psychological literature that there is a mental cost to the brain of switching between tasks. Various studies have been preferred which instruct subjects to jump between tasks, and then measure the time cost to performance. These are then compared with subjects who simply repeated the same task, instead of switching.

Here’s what one such study from 2001 found:

“Joshua Rubinstein, PhD, Jeffrey Evans, PhD, and David Meyer, PhD, conducted four experiments in which young adults switched between different tasks, such as solving math problems or classifying geometric objects. For all tasks, the participants lost time when they had to switch from one task to another. As tasks got more complex, participants lost more time. As a result, people took significantly longer to switch between more complex tasks. Time costs were also greater when the participants switched to tasks that were relatively unfamiliar. They got up to speed faster when they switched to tasks they knew better.”

What is the right way to multitask?

Kat Boogard at Trello, the productivity app, argues that multitasking and task switching should be understood separately.

Task switching, the aspect of multitasking generally studied in scientific research, is now understood by most to negatively affect performance and should be avoided. Task switching results in cognitive overload and a mental drag on performance, as you’re still thinking about the last activity as you start the next activity.

However, classic multitasking in the sense of combining multiple activities at the same time can be positive, as long as the activities are different enough that they don’t result in cognitive overload. Typically, this means combining activities that use different senses. For examples, think about biking and listening to a podcast, or taking a walk while talking to a friend on the phone. Forbes contributor Peter Bregman even posited a theoretically positive quadruple-tasking scenario: biking to work while planning your day covers the tasks of (1) commuting to work (2) exercising (3) preparation and (4) starting your day with positive energy.

Is mindfulness compatible with multitasking?

Although mindfulness isn’t generally associated with multitasking, that doesn’t mean that mindfulness practices won’t help you become a better multitasker.

A study by University of Washington Information School professors David Levy and Jacob Wobbrock studied three groups of people in a series of multitasking experiments. One group had been given eight weeks of meditation and mindfulness training, another eight weeks of body relaxation training, and the control group received no training.

The results showed that the meditation group reported lower levels of stress while multitasking than the other two groups.

Is mindfulness better than multitasking?

Mindfulness, or monotasking, is not better or worse than multitasking.

Multitasking is often the brain’s preferred way to get things done, and while we can strive towards monotasking and mindfulness, we’ll still face situations where we need to manage multiple tasks at once. Plus, while some people prefer monotasking, others thrive while juggling multiple tasks in a busy environment and a small percentage of us are supertaskers who face no productivity hit when multitasking.

However, research has shown that multitasking can lead to cognitive overload and can hamper productivity by up to 40%.

So whether you’re a monotasker or multitasker at heart, be aware of the research when planning your approach to work. And if you feel cognitive overload, consider approaching your day mindfully by taking on tasks one at a time, giving each your full attention.

Want More Content Like This?

Woman playing violin in a state of flow

Previous Post

Mindfulness vs Flow: What’s the Difference?

Next Post

Are Meditation Retreats Worth It?

Group of people on meditation retreat